Appraisal review involves the critical evaluation and commentary by one appraiser on the appraisal report prepared by another appraiser. This secondary review ensures quality, accuracy, and compliance with standards, such as those set forth by the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP).
Context and Importance
An appraisal review serves several critical functions:
- Quality Control: Ensures the original appraisal meets the required standards of accuracy and quality.
- Compliance: Verifies that the appraisal meets all pertinent regulatory standards, including USPAP guidelines.
- Risk Management: Helps to identify potential risks associated with valuation inaccuracies.
Processes in Appraisal Review
Steps in Conducting an Appraisal Review
- Initial Examination: A preliminary assessment of the appraisal report to check for major errors or omissions.
- Detailed Analysis: A thorough examination of the methodologies, data sources, and conclusions drawn in the report.
- Verification of Data: Ensuring that data presented in the report is accurate and verifiable.
- Compliance Check: Confirming that the appraisal adheres to USPAP and other relevant guidelines.
- Commentary and Feedback: Providing detailed feedback, including critiques and recommendations for improvements if necessary.
Key Aspects Evaluated
- Methodologies: Review of the approaches used (e.g., sales comparison approach, cost approach, income approach).
- Data Quality: Examination of the data sources and the integrity of the data used.
- Accuracy of Calculations: Checking for mathematical accuracy.
- Consistency: Ensuring the report is consistent in its analysis, findings, and conclusions.
- Presentation: Evaluating the clarity and professionalism of the report.
Standards and Regulations
USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice)
USPAP provides detailed guidelines for both conducting appraisals and appraisal reviews:
- Standard 3 (Appraisal Review, Development): Describes the requirements for developing an appraisal review.
- Standard 4 (Appraisal Review, Reporting): Covers the reporting requirements for an appraisal review.
Applicability
Real Estate
In real estate, appraisal reviews are essential for:
- Mortgage Lending: Ensuring the initial valuation is accurate for loan underwriting.
- Litigation: Supporting or contesting property valuations in legal disputes.
- Portfolio Management: Assisting institutional investors in maintaining accurate property valuations.
Finance and Banking
In finance and banking:
- Risk Management: Helping banks manage risks associated with asset valuation.
- Regulatory Compliance: Ensuring compliance with financial regulations.
Related Terms
- Appraisal (noun): A formal evaluation of property, typically including analysis of market data.
- Comparable Sales (noun): Recently sold properties with similar characteristics to the subject property, used in the sales comparison approach.
- Fair Market Value (noun): The price at which a property would sell under normal market conditions.
FAQs
What is the purpose of an appraisal review?
Who can perform an appraisal review?
How long does an appraisal review take?
References
- Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP): The Appraisal Foundation
- The Appraisal of Real Estate: Richard C. Sorenson, “Real Estate Valuation”
Summary
Appraisal reviews play a crucial role in maintaining the integrity and accuracy of property valuations. By adhering to standards, such as USPAP, and following a systematic review process, appraisers ensure that appraisals are reliable and fit for their intended purposes. This comprehensive evaluation is essential across various sectors, including real estate, finance, and banking, underpinning sound decision-making and risk management.
