Dealing Desk: A Setup for Internal Order Processing by Brokers

August 31, 2024 4 min read Finance Trading Dealing Desk Brokers Internal Order Processing Market Orders Trading Strategies

A detailed examination of how some brokers use a dealing desk to process orders internally, rather than routing them directly to the market.

On this page

A Dealing Desk is a mechanism used by some brokerage firms to internally process their clients’ trading orders instead of directly sending them to the financial markets. This process involves creating a market for clients by executing trade orders within the firm’s own infrastructure before reflecting these trades in the broader market.

What is a Dealing Desk? Definition and Overview

A Dealing Desk operates as an intermediary between traders and the market, often found within brokerage firms that offer over-the-counter (OTC) trading services. When clients place buy or sell orders, these orders are first processed and executed by the broker’s dealing desk, which then may or may not offset the covered position in the broader market.

Types of Brokerage Firms Handling Orders

Market-Making Brokers

Market-making brokers typically use a dealing desk to provide liquidity in the market. They quote bid and ask prices and are ready to buy assets from or sell assets to their clients.

Non-Dealing Desk Brokers

In contrast, non-dealing desk (NDD) brokers directly link clients’ trade orders with the market, typically through electronic communications networks (ECNs) or straight-through processing (STP), ensuring no intermediary involvement from the broker’s side.

Special Considerations in Using a Dealing Desk

Pros and Cons

Advantages

Liquidity Provision: Dealing desks can enhance market liquidity by ensuring that there are always parties ready to execute trades.
Enhanced Control: Brokers have greater control over trade execution, reducing market impact and slippage.
Stability: Can potentially provide more stable transaction costs and improve order fulfillment rates.

Disadvantages

Conflict of Interest: A potential conflict arises as brokers might trade against their clients.
Transaction Costs: Dealing desk services can sometimes involve higher spreads and fees compared to direct market access.

Examples and Historical Context

Real-World Examples

Retail Forex Trading: Many retail forex brokers utilize dealing desks to manage small-volume trades and offer fixed spreads.
OTC Derivatives: In the OTC derivatives market, dealing desks play a critical role in managing and hedging counterparty risk.

Historical Context

The concept of dealing desks dates back to the origins of brokerage services when physical trading floors dominated. With technological advancements, electronic trading systems have emerged, but dealing desks remain pivotal in ensuring liquidity and efficient trade execution in certain markets.

Applicability in Modern Trading

Who Uses Dealing Desks?

Dealing desks are commonly used by:

Retail Brokers: Providing consistent trading experience for small-volume traders.
Investment Banks: Managing large volumes of trades across various asset classes.
Hedge Funds: Offering more controlled execution environments for proprietary trading.

Comparisons with Non-Dealing Desk Setups

A key distinction between dealing desk and non-dealing desk brokers lies in the execution method:

Dealing Desk Brokers: Internalize the orders, potentially matching them with other clients.
Non-Dealing Desk Brokers: Pass the orders directly to the interbank market or liquidity providers.

Market Maker: A market maker is a broker or investment firm that provides liquidity to financial markets by being ready to buy and sell securities at publicly quoted prices.
ECN Brokers: ECN brokers use electronic communication networks to match buy and sell orders directly, operating without intermediaries.

FAQs

Is there a conflict of interest with dealing desk brokers?

Yes, since dealing desk brokers can take the opposite side of a client’s trade, there is an inherent conflict of interest that might influence how they execute orders.

Are dealing desk brokers suitable for high-frequency trading (HFT)?

Typically, dealing desk brokers are better suited for retail clients and specific trading strategies rather than high-frequency trading, which requires direct market access.

How do fixed spreads work in a dealing desk environment?

Dealing desk brokers often offer fixed spreads, ensuring clients know the cost of trades upfront, independent of market volatility.

References

“The Basics of Brokerage Operations,” Investopedia.
“Market Makers and Their Roles in Trading,” Financial Times.
“Understanding ECN and STP Brokers,” Forex.com.

Summary

The Dealing Desk remains a fundamental element in the financial markets for brokers to manage trade executions internally. While it provides liquidity and stability, it also poses potential conflicts of interest. Understanding the dynamics of dealing desks is crucial for traders and investors in selecting the appropriate brokerage service tailored to their trading needs and objectives.