Doing Business: Definition and Implications

August 25, 2024 4 min read Business Legal Business Practices Corporate Law State Jurisdiction Regulatory Compliance Business Activities

Understanding the concept of 'doing business', its legal implications, and the criteria used to determine whether a corporation is conducting business within a state.

On this page

“Doing business” refers to carrying on, conducting, or managing a business. In a legal context, it signifies that a company is engaged in activities that fulfill its organizational purpose and subjects it to state laws and jurisdiction.

Legal Context and Criteria

The determination of whether a corporation is doing business in a state involves an examination of its activities within that state. These can include:

Transaction of Business: Engaging in any business transactions or exchanges.
Physical Presence: Operating offices, branches, or facilities within the state.
Employees and Agents: Having employees or agents working within the state.
Contracts and Sales: Entering into contracts or making sales in the state.
Advertising: Prominent advertising and marketing efforts directed at residents of the state.

These activities indicate that the corporation is performing ordinary functions for which it was organized, and thus, it is subject to state laws and jurisdiction.

Special Considerations

Different states may have varying thresholds and criteria for what constitutes “doing business.” This can affect:

Tax Obligations: Corporations may need to pay state taxes or register for tax purposes.
Legal Requirements: Requirement to register as a foreign corporation in states where they conduct business.
Licenses and Permits: Obtaining necessary licenses or permits to legally operate in the state.
Jurisdiction: Being subject to the jurisdiction of state courts for legal matters.

Examples

Physical Store: A retail corporation opening a store in another state is “doing business” in that state.
Online Sales: If a company operates primarily online but has significant sales in a state, it may be considered to be doing business there.
Remote Employees: Having remote employees or contractors working from a specific state can subject the corporation to that state’s jurisdiction.

Historical Context

The concept of “doing business” has evolved alongside the expansion of interstate commerce and globalization. Initially, it was easier to define based on physical presence, but with the advent of e-commerce, the criteria have had to adapt.

Applicability

This concept is relevant across various domains:

Business Law: Determines the legal and regulatory requirements a corporation must fulfill.
Taxes: Affects state and local tax obligations.
Compliance: Ensures a business complies with state laws and avoids legal ramifications.
Strategic Planning: Assists corporations in deciding where and how to expand their operations.

Comparisons

Nexus: Similarly to “doing business,” the term “nexus” is often used in tax law to indicate a connection sufficient to tax a business.
Interstate Commerce: While “doing business” might refer to activities within a single state, interstate commerce involves business transactions crossing state lines, often regulated by federal law.

Foreign Corporation: A company incorporated in one state but doing business in another.
Unitary Business: Businesses that are interconnected and operating under common control across state lines.
Registered Agent: An individual or business responsible for receiving legal documents on behalf of the corporation within the state.

FAQs

When is a foreign corporation required to register in a state?

Generally, when the corporation is found to be doing business in that state according to the specific criteria set forth by state law.

How does online business impact the 'doing business' determination?

Significant online sales targeted at residents of a state can lead to a determination that a business is doing business within that state, especially if coupled with other activities.

What are the penalties for failing to register as a foreign corporation?

Penalties can include fines, inability to enforce contracts in state courts, and back taxes.

References

Business Law Texts: Refer to authoritative texts for detailed analysis and case law.
State Revenue Agencies: Guidelines often published by state authorities detailing what constitutes doing business for tax purposes.
Legal Precedents: Court cases that interpret and apply the criteria of doing business in various contexts.

Summary

“Doing business” is a fundamental concept in corporate and commercial law, indicating a corporation’s engagement in activities that subject it to state jurisdiction and regulatory responsibilities. Understanding the implications of doing business is crucial for compliance and strategic planning.

This definition provides a comprehensive look at what it means for a corporation to be doing business in a particular state, taking into account various criteria, legal interpretations, and practical examples.