Experience Study: Mortality Analysis

August 31, 2024 4 min read Statistics Insurance Finance Mortality Analysis Actuarial Science Expectations Actual Experience

An analysis comparing actual mortality experience to expected experience.

On this page

An experience study is a systematic analysis conducted to compare the actual mortality experience against the expected experience within a given population or cohort. This type of study is crucial for industries such as insurance, where it informs risk assessment, pricing policies, and reserve requirements.

Detailed Explanation

Overview of Experience Study

An experience study involves collecting data on the observed mortality or other relevant factors over a specific period. This data is then compared to the expected outcomes, which are based on statistical models, historical data, or assumptions used in actuarial calculations. The primary purpose of this study is to identify discrepancies between expected and actual outcomes to refine future forecasting models.

Purpose and Importance

Conducting experience studies holds multiple benefits:

Risk Management: By identifying trends and anomalies in actual experience, organizations can better manage and mitigate risks.
Pricing and Reserves: Accurate mortality data ensures that insurance products are priced correctly and that sufficient reserves are maintained to cover future claims.
Model Refinement: Continuous comparison between actual and expected data helps refine predictive models and improve their accuracy.
Regulatory Compliance: Many jurisdictions require insurers to conduct regular experience studies to ensure that their pricing models and reserves are actuarially sound.

Methodology

Data Collection

Data sources include insurance claims, policyholder records, and demographic statistics. Ensuring data accuracy and consistency is vital for an effective study.

Expected Mortality Calculation

Expected mortality rates are often derived using life tables or statistical models that account for various factors such as age, gender, health status, and lifestyle.

E_x = \sum_{i=1}^{n} p_i \cdot q_i

where:

\( E_x \) is the expected number of deaths in the study period.
\( p_i \) is the probability of death at age \( i \).
\( q_i \) is the actual number of individuals at risk at age \( i \).

Actual Mortality Calculation

This involves tallying the actual number of deaths observed within the same period.

A_x = \sum_{i=1}^{n} d_i

where:

\( A_x \) is the actual number of deaths observed.
\( d_i \) is the number of deaths at age \( i \).

Comparison and Analysis

The key metric often used in experience studies is the Mortality Ratio \( MR \):

MR = \frac{A_x}{E_x}

If \( MR > 1 \), actual mortality exceeds expectations.
If \( MR < 1 \), actual mortality is lower than expected.
If \( MR = 1 \), actual mortality matches expected mortality.

Types of Experience Studies

Mortality Studies: Compare actual death rates to expected rates.
Morbidity Studies: Compare actual incidence of sickness or disability to expectations.
Surrender Studies: Assess policyholder behavior regarding the early termination of policies.

Historical Context

Experience studies have been central to actuarial science since the 19th century. They gained prominence with the rise of life insurance companies, which relied on accurate predictions of life expectancy to remain solvent. Over time, advancements in statistical techniques and data collection have markedly improved the efficacy of these studies.

Modern Applications

In today’s context, experience studies play a vital role in:

Dynamic Pricing: Adjusting premiums based on recent trends.
Customized Products: Creating insurance products tailored to specific demographics.
Regulation and Oversight: Ensuring that policies comply with regulatory standards.

Actuarial Science: The discipline that applies mathematical and statistical methods to assess risk in insurance, finance, and other industries.
Life Table: A table showing the probability of surviving each year of age.
Expected Mortality: The anticipated rate of death within a population, based on historical data and statistical models.

FAQs

Why are experience studies essential for insurers?

Experience studies help insurers evaluate the accuracy of their mortality assumptions, aiding in better risk management and pricing strategies.

How frequently should experience studies be conducted?

While the frequency can vary, many insurers conduct annual experience studies to keep their models and assumptions current.

What challenges exist in conducting experience studies?

Key challenges include ensuring data accuracy, accounting for population heterogeneity, and dealing with small sample sizes that may not be statistically significant.

References

Dorin, A. (2015). Actuarial Mathematics for Life Contingent Risks.
Haberman, S., & Pitacco, E. (2009). Actuarial Models for Disability Insurance.
C.M. Trowbridge. (1989). Fundamentals of Actuarial Science.

Summary

Experience studies are a critical analytical tool within the insurance and actuarial fields. By comparing actual mortality rates to those expected, these studies ensure more accurate risk assessment, pricing, and regulatory compliance. Though complex, they are indispensable for maintaining financial stability and regulatory adherence in risk-related industries.