Gain Sharing: Employee Motivational Technique

August 25, 2024 4 min read Management Economics Business Employee Motivation Performance Incentives Compensation Strategies Team-Based Incentives Organizational Efficiency

Gain Sharing is a motivational technique in which employees are compensated for measurable performance gains in areas such as sales, customer satisfaction, and cost reductions, often given to teams for achieving specified goals.

On this page

Gain sharing is an employee motivational technique in which compensation is linked to measurable improvements in performance. This approach focuses on specific, quantifiable goals such as sales growth, customer satisfaction, and cost reductions. Unlike individual incentives, gain sharing often rewards teams for their collective achievements.

Definition and Concept

Gain sharing operates under the principle that both employees and the organization benefit from improved performance. The technique encourages synergy and collective effort:

\text{Gain Sharing Bonus} = f(\text{Performance Gain})

Where:

\( \text{Gain Sharing Bonus} \) is the compensation awarded.
\( \text{Performance Gain} \) represents the measurable improvements.

Scanlon Plan

The Scanlon Plan emphasizes participative management and focuses on reducing labor costs relative to productivity. Employees receive bonuses based on a formula comparing labor costs to the value of production.

Rucker Plan

The Rucker Plan links bonuses to the value-added by the production process. It uses a formula where bonuses are proportionate to productivity improvements, emphasizing operational efficiency.

Improshare

Improshare (Improved Productivity through Sharing) measures productivity improvements and shares the savings with employees. Unlike the Scanlon and Rucker Plans, Improshare uses a pre-set baseline to determine performance improvements.

When implementing gain sharing, several considerations are essential for success:

Clear Objectives: Goals must be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART).
Transparent Metrics: Employees should understand how performance is measured and how it influences compensation.
Effective Communication: Regular updates and feedback ensure employees remain engaged and informed.
Team Cohesion: Promoting teamwork and collaboration is crucial for achieving collective goals.

Sales Growth

A company sets a target for sales growth over a quarter. If the team exceeds this target, they receive a percentage of the additional revenue as a bonus.

Customer Satisfaction

An organization may implement a gain-sharing plan where bonuses are based on improvements in customer satisfaction scores. Achievements are measured through surveys and feedback mechanisms.

Cost Reductions

A manufacturing firm introduces a plan where employees share the savings from reduced operational costs. Savings could come from process improvements, waste reduction, or resource optimization.

Historical Context

The concept of gain sharing originated in the early 20th century. Joseph Scanlon, a labor leader, and theorist, developed the Scanlon Plan in the 1930s to encourage efficiency and productivity in manufacturing. Since then, various forms of gain sharing have evolved, adapting to different industries and organizational structures.

Applicability and Benefits

Gain sharing is applicable in diverse industries, including manufacturing, retail, and services. The benefits include:

Enhanced Performance: Direct linkage between performance and rewards motivates employees.
Cost Efficiency: Encourages employees to identify and implement cost-saving measures.
Teamwork: Fosters collaboration and a sense of shared purpose.
Employee Engagement: Increases motivation and job satisfaction through tangible rewards.

Gain Sharing: Focuses on operational performance metrics and distributes rewards based on measurable gains. Typically shared among teams.
Profit Sharing: Tied to overall profitability of the company, often distributed company-wide and may be influenced by factors outside the employee’s control.

Performance Incentives: Broader category of rewards based on individual or group performance.
Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP): Provides employees with stock ownership in the company, often used to align employee interests with shareholders.
Merit Pay: Incremental salary increases based on individual performance appraisals.

FAQs

How is gain sharing different from traditional bonuses?

Gain sharing is linked to specific, measurable performance improvements, often at the team level, while traditional bonuses may be discretionary and based on an individual’s overall performance or company profitability.

What metrics are commonly used in gain sharing plans?

Common metrics include sales growth, customer satisfaction scores, productivity ratios, and cost reductions.

Can gain sharing be used in small businesses?

Yes, gain sharing can be adapted to businesses of all sizes and can be particularly effective in small businesses where collaborative efforts directly impact performance.

How are gain sharing bonuses calculated?

Bonuses are typically calculated using pre-determined formulas that relate performance metrics to financial rewards. These formulas vary based on the specific gain sharing plan in use (Scanlon, Rucker, Improshare, etc.).

What challenges might organizations face with gain sharing?

Challenges include setting appropriate and achievable goals, maintaining transparent metrics, ensuring ongoing employee engagement, and avoiding potential conflicts within teams.

References

“The Scanlon Plan for Organization Development,” Joseph Scanlon, 1938.
“Gain Sharing and Group Incentives,” Edward Lawler, 1978.
“Implementing Gainsharing and Employee Participation,” Paul D. Sweeney, 1991.

Summary

Gain sharing is a powerful motivational tool that aligns employee incentives with organizational goals. By rewarding teams based on measurable performance improvements, gain sharing fosters collaboration, enhances productivity, and drives cost efficiency. Understanding its types, historical context, and implementation considerations can help organizations effectively leverage this technique for sustainable success.