What Is Subgame Perfect Equilibrium?

A detailed exploration of Subgame Perfect Equilibrium, its historical context, importance in game theory, mathematical formulation, and applications in economics, finance, and strategic decision-making.

Subgame Perfect Equilibrium: A Refinement of Nash Equilibrium

Historical Context

Subgame perfect equilibrium (SPE) emerged from the field of game theory, which examines strategic interactions among rational decision-makers. It refines Nash equilibrium by ensuring that strategies are optimal at every point in the game. The concept was formally introduced by Reinhard Selten in 1965, who later won a Nobel Prize in Economics in 1994 for his contributions to game theory.

Types/Categories

  1. Finite Sequential Games: SPE is commonly used in games with a finite number of stages.
  2. Infinite Sequential Games: Though less common, SPE can apply to infinite-horizon games where players’ decisions unfold indefinitely.

Key Events

  • 1950s: John Nash introduces Nash Equilibrium.
  • 1965: Reinhard Selten introduces Subgame Perfect Equilibrium.
  • 1994: Selten receives the Nobel Prize in Economics for his work on game theory.

Detailed Explanations

Subgame Perfect Equilibrium refines Nash equilibrium by considering the strategies at every possible point in the game. It ensures that no player can improve their outcome by deviating from their strategy, not just at the start but at every subgame stage.

Backward Induction: The method used to find SPE involves backward induction:

  1. Start from the end: Begin by analyzing the last move of the game.
  2. Optimal strategies: Determine the optimal strategy for the last player to move.
  3. Move backward: Use this information to determine the optimal strategy for the preceding moves.

Mathematical Formulation

To find the SPE using backward induction in a sequential game, one can use the following steps:

  1. Identify all subgames in the original game.
  2. For each subgame, solve the Nash equilibrium starting from the last move of the subgame.
  3. Move backward, determining the Nash equilibrium for preceding moves considering previously computed strategies.

Charts and Diagrams

Here is a mermaid diagram illustrating backward induction in a simple sequential game:

    graph TD
	    A[Start] --> B[Player 1's Decision]
	    B --> C1[Player 2's Decision (L)]
	    B --> C2[Player 2's Decision (R)]
	    C1 --> D1[Payoff (3,2)]
	    C2 --> D2[Payoff (1,4)]

Importance and Applicability

Economics and Finance: SPE is essential in understanding market behaviors, auctions, bargaining scenarios, and more. Political Science: Used to analyze strategic moves in political campaigns, elections, and legislative processes. Business and Management: Helpful in strategic decision-making, negotiations, and competitive strategies.

Examples

Ultimatum Game: In this game, one player proposes a split of money, and the other player accepts or rejects it. Using backward induction, we find that the proposer will offer the smallest amount acceptable to the responder. Chess: The game of chess can be analyzed using SPE to determine optimal moves at every stage of the game.

Considerations

When using SPE, consider:

  • Complexity: The method can become computationally intense in large games.
  • Common Knowledge of Rationality: Assumes that all players are rational and this fact is common knowledge.
  1. Nash Equilibrium: A strategy set where no player can benefit by unilaterally changing their strategy.
  2. Sequential Game: A game where players make decisions one after another.
  3. Backward Induction: A method to solve finite extensive form or sequential games by analyzing from the end of the game to the beginning.

Comparisons

Nash Equilibrium vs. Subgame Perfect Equilibrium:

  • Nash Equilibrium: Applies to simultaneous-move games and might include non-credible threats.
  • Subgame Perfect Equilibrium: Applies to sequential-move games and eliminates non-credible threats by ensuring optimal strategies at every subgame.

Interesting Facts

  • Real-world Application: SPE has been used to analyze complex negotiations such as international trade agreements and corporate mergers.
  • Nobel Prize: Reinhard Selten’s contribution to the concept of SPE earned him a Nobel Prize.

Inspirational Stories

  • Nobel Prize: The story of Reinhard Selten, who developed the concept of SPE and won a Nobel Prize, inspires many in the field of economics and beyond.

Famous Quotes

  • “Games are won by players who focus on the playing field –- not by those whose eyes are glued to the scoreboard.” – Warren Buffett (Applicable to strategic decision-making in game theory)

Proverbs and Clichés

  • “Look before you leap.” (Encourages considering all future consequences before making a decision, relevant in backward induction).

Expressions

  • Playing the Long Game: Refers to making strategic decisions considering long-term outcomes, akin to backward induction in SPE.

Jargon and Slang

  • Subgame: A part of the game that can be analyzed as a separate game.
  • Credible Threat: A strategy that a rational player would actually follow through.

FAQs

Q1: What is the difference between a Nash Equilibrium and a Subgame Perfect Equilibrium? A1: A Nash Equilibrium applies to entire games, while Subgame Perfect Equilibrium applies to all subgames within a game, eliminating non-credible threats.

Q2: How is Subgame Perfect Equilibrium found? A2: It is typically found using backward induction, analyzing the game from the end to the beginning.

References

  1. Fudenberg, D., & Tirole, J. (1991). “Game Theory”. MIT Press.
  2. Osborne, M. J., & Rubinstein, A. (1994). “A Course in Game Theory”. MIT Press.
  3. Myerson, R. B. (1991). “Game Theory: Analysis of Conflict”. Harvard University Press.

Summary

Subgame Perfect Equilibrium (SPE) is a crucial concept in game theory refining Nash equilibrium by ensuring that strategies are optimal at every stage of the game. Introduced by Reinhard Selten, SPE is widely used in economics, finance, political science, and strategic business decisions. The method of backward induction is typically employed to identify SPE. Understanding SPE enhances our ability to predict rational outcomes in complex sequential scenarios, reinforcing its importance in theoretical and practical applications.

Finance Dictionary Pro

Our mission is to empower you with the tools and knowledge you need to make informed decisions, understand intricate financial concepts, and stay ahead in an ever-evolving market.