Suggestion System: Method of Eliciting Worker Suggestions for Management

A comprehensive exploration of suggestion systems, focusing on their role in eliciting worker suggestions for management and obtaining employee feedback.

A Suggestion System is an organized method used by organizations to gather input, ideas, and feedback from employees. These systems are designed to encourage workers to submit suggestions that can lead to improved processes, increased efficiency, innovation, and overall organizational improvements.

How Suggestion Systems Work

  • Submission of Ideas: Employees submit suggestions through various channels such as suggestion boxes, online portals, or dedicated meetings.
  • Evaluation: A committee or designated personnel assess the feasibility, potential benefits, and implementation costs of the suggestions.
  • Incentives: Many systems offer bonuses or recognition for particularly valuable or cost-effective ideas, motivating employees to participate actively.

Types of Suggestion Systems

Formal Suggestion Systems

These systems have structured processes, including official forms, predefined evaluation criteria, and clear feedback mechanisms. They tend to be more bureaucratic but can handle large volumes of suggestions effectively.

Informal Suggestion Systems

An informal suggestion system may include casual conversations, open-door policies, or more flexible submission processes. These systems can be quicker and less intimidating, fostering a more spontaneous flow of ideas.

Special Considerations

  • Anonymity: Allowing anonymous submissions can lead to more honest and innovative suggestions.
  • Transparency: Clear communication about the evaluation process and criteria can build trust among employees.
  • Follow-Up: Regular updates on the status of suggestions reassure employees that their input is valued and taken seriously.

Examples of Suggestion Systems

  • Toyota’s Continuous Improvement (“Kaizen”): Employees are encouraged to constantly seek improvements in all aspects of the manufacturing process.
  • Google’s “20% Time”: Engineers are allowed to spend 20% of their time working on projects they are passionate about, leading to innovations like Gmail.

Historical Context

The concept of suggestion systems dates back to early 20th century manufacturing environments, where the aim was to harness the collective intelligence of the workforce to solve operational problems. Their modern iteration often has roots in the Kaizen approach of continuous improvement.

Applicability

Suggestion systems are applicable across various sectors including manufacturing, services, healthcare, education, and technology. They are beneficial for:

Comparisons

  • Suggestion Box: A simple, traditional form of suggestion system, usually a physical repository for ideas.
  • Quality Circles: Small groups of employees meeting regularly to discuss and solve work-related problems.
  • Innovation Platforms: Digital tools facilitating idea submission and collaboration across broader networks.
  • Suggestion Box: A physical or digital repository where employees can submit their ideas.
  • Kaizen: A Japanese term meaning “continuous improvement” involving all employees.
  • Employee Feedback System: Broader systems that include suggestions as well as other types of feedback.

FAQs

Why should companies implement suggestion systems?

To harness the collective intelligence of their employees, foster innovation, and improve processes while enhancing employee engagement.

How can companies ensure the success of suggestion systems?

By ensuring transparency, providing timely feedback, recognizing valuable contributions, and maintaining flexible submission methods.

What are the common barriers to effective suggestion systems?

Lack of trust in the system, fear of reprisal, poor communication, and inadequately structured follow-up processes can hinder success.

References

  • Doymaz, R. (2023). Employee Suggestion Systems: A Comprehensive Guide. Industry Press.
  • Ishikawa, K. (1985). What Is Total Quality Control? The Japanese Way. Prentice Hall.

Summary

A suggestion system is a strategic tool for organizations to elicit valuable input from their employees, fostering a culture of continuous improvement and innovation. Featuring both formal and informal types, these systems thrive on transparent processes, timely feedback, and incentives to maximize participation and effectiveness. From traditional suggestion boxes to expansive innovation platforms, these systems provide a pathway to operational excellence and enhanced employee engagement.

Finance Dictionary Pro

Our mission is to empower you with the tools and knowledge you need to make informed decisions, understand intricate financial concepts, and stay ahead in an ever-evolving market.