Tenancy In Common (TIC) is a form of property co-ownership where two or more individuals simultaneously own a fraction of an asset. Unlike other ownership structures, such as Joint Tenancy, TIC allows for unequal ownership percentages and flexible transfer of ownership rights.
Owners in a TIC have an undivided interest in the property, meaning they have equal rights to use the entire property rather than specific parts of it. These interests can be inherited or sold independently of other co-owners.
Key Features of Tenancy In Common
Undivided Interest
Each owner in a TIC arrangement holds an undivided interest in the property. This means that even if ownership proportions vary among tenants, each co-owner possesses the same rights to use and enjoy the entire property.
Flexible Ownership Shares
TIC agreements provide flexibility in ownership percentages. The shares can be distributed unevenly among co-owners, allowing for varied investment contributions.
Independent Transferability
Ownership shares in a TIC can be transferred independently. Co-owners can sell or pass their individual shares through inheritance without requiring the consent of the other co-owners.
TIC and Section 1031 Tax-Free Exchanges
What is Section 1031?
Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code allows for the deferral of capital gains taxes on the exchange of like-kind properties. This provision encourages investment in like-kind properties by enabling taxpayers to defer taxes on exchanged properties.
TIC in Section 1031 Exchanges
TIC structures have historically been used to facilitate Section 1031 exchanges. By converting a property into a TIC arrangement, investors can exchange partial interests in properties rather than entire properties. This flexibility often allows for more manageable and diversified investments.
Investor Concerns
While TICs can aid in tax deferral strategies, some investors feel that the value received may sometimes be inadequate compared to direct property ownership. This inadequacy often arises from perceived risks associated with co-ownership dynamics, such as potential disputes among co-owners and fluctuations in property values.
Examples and Applications
Real Estate Investments
TIC agreements are commonly used in real estate investments, particularly for commercial properties. Investors can pool resources to acquire larger properties that would be unattainable individually.
Estate Planning
TIC is also used in estate planning, allowing property owners to pass fractional interests to heirs without altering the co-ownership structure for other tenants.
Historical Context
The TIC structure has roots in traditional property law, providing a common method for multiple individuals to co-own real estate since ancient times. Its fit within the modern investment landscape has been shaped largely by legal developments, particularly the introduction of tax-deferral benefits under Section 1031.
Comparisons to Other Co-Ownership Structures
Tenancy by the Entirety
- Ownership: Only available to married couples.
- Survivorship: Includes right of survivorship, meaning the property automatically passes to the surviving spouse upon one’s death.
- Indivisibility: Ownership cannot be transferred without both spouses’ consent.
Joint Tenancy
- Ownership: Equal ownership shares.
- Survivorship: Includes right of survivorship.
- Unity of Time: Requires all tenants to acquire their interest simultaneously.
Community Property
- Ownership: Only recognized in certain states and applicable to married couples.
- Equal Share: Each spouse has an equal interest in the property acquired during marriage.
- Survivorship: Does not automatically include the right of survivorship.
FAQs
Can a TIC agreement be terminated?
What happens if a TIC owner wants to sell their share?
How is income from a TIC property divided?
Summary
Tenancy In Common (TIC) is a versatile and flexible method of co-owning property that allows for varied ownership shares and independent transferability of interests. It holds significant value in real estate investments and estate planning, though it also poses specific risks and challenges. Particularly relevant within Section 1031 tax-free exchanges, TICs enable strategic tax deferral benefits, though investor satisfaction may vary based on individual circumstances and market dynamics.
References
- Internal Revenue Code, Section 1031.
- U.S. Department of the Treasury, IRS guidelines on Like-Kind Exchanges.
- “Modern Real Estate Practice” by Fillmore W. Galaty, Wellington J. Allaway, and Robert C. Kyle.
End of Entry.
