Definition
A zombie bank is an insolvent financial institution that remains in operation only due to explicit or implicit government support. These banks are financially unstable and would otherwise be unable to survive in an open market without such interventions.
Characteristics
Zombie banks are distinguished by several key characteristics:
- Insolvency: They possess liabilities that exceed their assets.
- Government Support: They rely on continual direct or indirect government assistance.
- Operational Continuity: Despite insolvency, they continue to operate, often extending non-performing loans.
- Economic Stagnation: They contribute to broader economic inefficiencies by tying up capital that could be used more productively elsewhere.
Mechanisms Behind Zombie Banks
Insolvency and Government Intervention
Zombie banks often emerge following significant economic or financial crises. To prevent widespread economic disruption, governments might provide bailouts, guarantees, or other forms of assistance to keep these banks operational.
Capital Adequacy and Regulatory Forbearance
Regulatory bodies may practice forbearance, allowing zombie banks to evade standard capital adequacy requirements temporarily. This leniency helps these institutions avoid immediate failure but can also delay necessary restructuring or liquidation.
Examples of Government Support
- Bailouts: Direct financial assistance to shore up balance sheets.
- Guarantees: Promises to back the bank’s liabilities, thus maintaining depositor and investor confidence.
- Low-Interest Loans: Providing access to cheap capital to ease short-term financial pressures.
Historical Context and Real-World Examples
Japan’s Lost Decade
During the 1990s, Japan experienced what is often referred to as the “Lost Decade,” characterized in part by the presence of numerous zombie banks. Following a real estate and stock market collapse, the Japanese government provided extensive support to its banking sector, leading to prolonged economic stagnation.
The 2008 Financial Crisis
The global financial crisis of 2008 also saw the emergence of zombie banks, particularly in the United States and Europe. Significant government interventions, including the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) in the U.S., helped prevent bank failures but also led to the survival of some zombie institutions.
Broader Economic Implications
Resource Misallocation
Zombie banks often extend credit to inefficient projects or firms (sometimes called “zombie firms”), furthering economic resource misallocation. This behavior can stifle economic growth and innovation, as capital gets trapped in unproductive uses.
Market Distortion
Continued government support for zombie banks can distort financial markets. Competitors might face unfair competition, and healthy banks could suffer from spillover effects due to negative perception.
Comparisons and Related Terms
Non-Performing Loans (NPLs)
Non-Performing Loans are loans in default or close to being in default. Zombie banks often have high levels of NPLs but continue to operate due to support mechanisms.
Bailout vs Bail-In
A bailout involves external assistance to rescue a bank, often using public funds. A bail-in restructures the bank’s debt internally by having creditors and depositors bear a portion of the losses.
FAQs
What is a zombie firm?
How do zombie banks affect economic recovery?
Can zombie banks eventually recover without government help?
References
- Kashyap, Anil K., et al. “Zombie Lending and Depressed Restructuring in Japan.”
- Hoshi, Takeo, and Anil K. Kashyap. “Japan’s Financial Crisis and Economic Stagnation.”
- Veronesi, Pietro, and Luigi Zingales. “Paulson’s Gift.”
- International Monetary Fund. “Global Financial Stability Report.”
Summary
Zombie banks, institutions that are insolvent yet operational due to government support, present significant economic challenges. They illustrate the delicate balance between preventing systemic failures and promoting economic efficiency. Understanding the mechanisms and implications of zombie banks is crucial for fiscal policy and financial regulation.
